Short answer: do not pay immediately. First check your credit notes. GSTR-1 shows invoices in Table 4 and credit notes separately in Table 9B, while GSTR-3B Table 3.1 is net. If the credit note equals the gap, explain it in ASMT-11 within 30 days, with proof.
Example reconciliation
| Item | Taxable value |
|---|---|
| GSTR-1 Table 4A | โน10,00,000 |
| Less: credit note in Table 9B | โน1,00,000 |
| Equals GSTR-3B Table 3.1(a) | โน9,00,000 |
What the three forms mean
- ASMT-10: the officer lists the differences and asks you to explain (Section 61, Rule 99).
- ASMT-11: your reply within 30 days. Explain with proof, or accept and pay by DRC-03.
- ASMT-12: the officer accepts the reply and the matter closes.
If you do not reply, or the reply is not satisfactory, the case can move to an audit or a show cause notice.
Sample ASMT-11 reply
1. The difference of taxable value โน1,00,000 and tax โน18,000 for August 2026 is due to Credit Note CN/2026-27/0007 dated 24-08-2026, against invoice GF/2026-27/0212, for goods returned.
2. The invoice is in Table 4A of GSTR-1, and the credit note is in Table 9B of the same return.
3. Table 3.1(a) of GSTR-3B is net of the credit note: โน10,00,000 less โน1,00,000 = โน9,00,000.
4. There is no short payment of tax. A copy of the credit note is attached.
Use your own facts. If tax really is short, accept that part and pay it by DRC-03. For the full process, read our ASMT-10 guide.
Practise it before you need it
You can try an ASMT-10 notice and ASMT-11 reply on IndIaTaxSim, an educational GST simulator. Nothing you enter goes to the real portal, and all the data is demo data. Your first practice GST registration is free, and course Modules 1, 2 and 10 are free to watch.
This page is general education, not tax or legal advice for your own case. For real filings, use the official GST portals.
๐ Continue Learning
๐ You Might Also Like
IndIaTaxSim Team
GST compliance experts building India's most complete GST simulation platform. All articles are reviewed for accuracy against the latest GSTN portal updates.
